GUMSHOE
Journal

Circular design starts with a specific question.

What the GUMSHOE example contributes to circular design, and how to turn a broad idea into a useful product brief.

Circular design starts with a specific question.
Original GUMSHOE project image · see the page sources and credits.

The context in Fjord Trends 2019

Fjord Trends 2019 mentions Gumshoe in its discussion of companies rethinking waste and their wider impact. The short example points to gum from Amsterdam’s streets becoming a shoe material. The full report covers many sectors; its broader statistics are not GUMSHOE product measurements.

Translate an idea into a product question

Instead of beginning with “make a sustainable sneaker”, begin with a more specific question: can a named waste stream become a useful component? Then define what the component has to do, which input can be traced and what records would let someone evaluate the result.

GUMSHOE makes that question visible through its sole and city reference. It gives readers an object to inspect, rather than leaving the idea as an abstract claim.

A brief you can actually use

Part of the briefPrompt
InputWhat exact waste stream is being used?
ComponentWhere does it go in the product?
FunctionWhat does that component need to do?
EvidenceWhich records connect the input and finished component?
UseWhat fit, care and condition information does the user need?
After useWhich real repair, reuse or collection route is available?

Worked example: a sole

Input: the gum waste described in the GUMSHOE project. Component: outsole. Material expertise: Gumdrop’s Gum-tec compounds. Visible design: Amsterdam map pattern. Remaining questions: model-specific composition, performance data, fit and an end-of-use route.

This example keeps the documented facts and open questions side by side. It does not invent a life-cycle result or turn the source into a factory audit.

Read a material claim in four fields
Read a material claim in four fields
  1. COMPONENT: Which exact part contains recycled input?
  2. QUANTITY: Is the share and its measurement basis stated?
  3. EVIDENCE: Which product-specific document supports it?
  4. AFTER USE: Is there a route accepting the finished product?
Based on the accompanying article and its cited sources; not a factory specification.

Sources & image credits

Original GUMSHOE photography and project images retain their source credits. New diagrams are original explanatory work.

Turn a circular-design question into a testable brief

The Ellen MacArthur Foundation’s design exercise starts with a specific challenge and small, measurable opportunities. Use the worksheet below to move beyond “make a circular shoe”. It is a fictional design proposal, not a new GUMSHOE model, a repair instruction for the current pair or a claim that a production test has taken place.

Complete one narrow example

Question: could a clearly identified replaceable fastening help keep a hypothetical shoe usable? The component is deliberately hypothetical. Its construction, compatibility and safety are unknown. Do not assume that an existing GUMSHOE fastening is user-replaceable. A qualified product team would first need the actual design and supplier documentation.

  1. State the need: preserve useful wear when only the fastening is damaged. Separate this user need from a claim about waste saved. Neither a percentage reduction nor an extended lifespan is established.
  2. Choose the comparison: draw two paper layouts, A with an unspecified fixed component and B with a proposed replaceable one. List the intended removal steps, required information and access points. A drawing can reveal an unanswered design question; it cannot demonstrate footwear durability.
  3. Set the evidence gate: before calling B replaceable, require a defined compatible part, documented replacement method, relevant safety checks and evidence for the assembled product. Mark all four pending in this example.
  4. Define failure: reject the proposal if replacement damages another component, the part cannot be obtained or the resulting shoe cannot meet its required function. Do not hide these outcomes behind a circularity score.
  5. Plan the next decision: ask the responsible designer for construction records and decide whether a supervised prototype study is justified. No customer information, real pair modification or payment is needed to complete this brief.

Edit your own working copy

The field is editable in this page and has no submit action. It does not deliberately save or transmit the text; a reload can discard your changes. Copy it to your own document if needed. Use product questions rather than personal information. Empty or unknown fields mean “not yet established”, not an automatic pass.

Keep the completed brief with its dated evidence list. The historical GUMSHOE material story remains separate from this proposed design: an interesting circular-design question is a starting point, not certification that the finished product is repairable or recyclable.

A fictional design brief connects one component to an A/B paper comparison, required evidence and explicit failure conditions.
A design proposal is not a product test or current GUMSHOE specification. © GUMSHOE · CC BY 4.0.

Ellen MacArthur Foundation · Find circular opportunities · 28 September 2016